Murphys, California Personal Injury Lawyers

Frank L. Russell
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Sonora, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 6 years experience
(209) 533-1883 32 N Washington St
 Sonora, CA 95370-4709
Personal Injury, Construction, Estate Planning and Real Estate
Stanford University
View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
David Carl Beyersdorf
Claimed Lawyer ProfileQ&A
Sonora, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 16 years experience
(209) 533-8636 195 South Washington Street
 Sonora, CA 95370
Personal Injury, Criminal, DUI and Domestic Violence
Seattle University School of Law
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Carrie Marie McKernan
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Sonora, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 2 years experience
(209) 533-1883 32 N Washington St
 Sonora, CA 95370
Personal Injury, Construction, Estate Planning and Real Estate
View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Bradley Lowell Young
Sonora, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 32 years experience
(209) 536-2750 995 Morning Star Dr
 Sonora, CA 95370
Personal Injury, Business and Real Estate
Santa Clara Univ School of Law
View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Richard Daniel Matranga
Sonora, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 44 years experience
(209) 532-2657 94 N Washington St
 Sonora, CA 95370
Personal Injury, Municipal and Real Estate
Santa Clara Univ School of Law
View Lawyer Profile
Thomas Allen Johnson
Sonora, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 33 years experience
(209) 536-6596 14019 Stanton Cir
 Sonora, CA 95370
Personal Injury and Insurance Defense
American U Washington COL
View Lawyer Profile
Michael Macomber
Sonora, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 36 years experience
(209) 536-9271 316 S Stewart St
 Sonora, CA 95370
Personal Injury
Willamette Univ COL
View Lawyer Profile
Stephen Adrian Derkum
Twain Harte, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 50 years experience
(209) 586-5250 22599 Spruce Dr
 Twain Harte, CA 95383
Personal Injury and Medical Malpractice
Southwestern Univ School of Law
View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
James Clifford Anderson
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Turlock, CA Personal Injury Attorney
(209) 667-2300 300 N. Palm St.
 Turlock, CA 95381
Personal Injury, Employment, Estate Planning and Landlord Tenant
University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
James practices in the areas of employment law for management, personal injury, estate planning, and real estate. James graduated from Arizona State University, in Tempe, Arizona, where he earned a Bachelor of Arts degree in Psychology. He went on to earn his J.D. from the University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, Sacramento, where he graduated fifth in his class, With Great Distinction, and Order of the Coif. While at McGeorge, James completed a judicial externship with the Honorable Justice George Nicholson, at the California Court of Appeal, Third Appellate District, in Sacramento. ...
Andrew S. Mendlin
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 22 years experience
(800) 529-3080 1300 K St
2nd Floor
 Modesto, CA 95354
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury
University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Maria C. Jaime
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 14 years experience
(800) 529-3080 1300 K St
2nd Floor
 Modesto, CA 95354
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury
Lincoln Law School
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Douglas Alan Goss
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Stockton, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 28 years experience
(209) 373-4680 3439 Brookside Road
Suite 205
 Stockton, CA 95219
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Criminal, DUI and Insurance Claims
Humphrey's Coll School of Law
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
I have been practicing law in San Joaquin county for over 28 years. Before becoming an attorney, I worked in San Joaquin County law enforcement for over 15 years. I have successfully resolved thousands of cases here. I know the area, and am familiar with the legal community. I provide legal representation and services ranging from major felony criminal defense, DUI defense, misdemeanor defense, personal injury, traffic tickets, expungements, and other forms of clearing your criminal record. If I don't practice in the area of law you need, I will make sure to find a high quality attorney who can...
Emery Brett Ledger
Claimed Lawyer ProfileBlawgsearchSocial Media
Stockton, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 19 years experience
2525 Pacific Avenue
 Stockton, CA 95204
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Nursing Home and Products Liability
Pepperdine University School of Law
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Fifteen years ago, I was sitting at my computer, wedged between a steaming coffee maker to my left and my fledgling law firm’s first associate three feet to my right. Today I’m humbled to have 10,000 square feet working alongside the best lawyers and paralegals in the world. It is now time for me to give back. I’m conservative on some issues and liberal on others, but high-minded about them all. I will always be politically active, but have no desire to be a political activist; striving instead to find Veritas Aequitas = Truth &...
15437 Anacapa Road
 Victorville, CA 92393
777 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way
 Palm Springs, CA 92262
516 W Shaw Avenue
 Fresno, CA 93704
701 E. Santa Clara Street
 Ventura, CA 93001
(800) 300-0001 11801 Pierce Street
 Riverside, CA 92505
(800) 300-0001 8333 Foothill Blvd.
 San Bernardino, CA 91730
(800) 300-0001 4900 California Avenue
 Bakersfield, CA 93309
(408) 850-9694 2033 Gateway Place
 San Jose, CA 95110
(800) 300-0001 1300 Clay Street
 Oakland, CA 94612
(800) 300-0001 101 California Street
 San Francisco, CA 94111
(800) 300-0001 980 Ninth Street
 Sacramento, CA 95814
(800) 300-0001 402 West Broadway
 San Diego, CA 92101
(800) 300-0001 811 Wilshire Blvd
Suite 1000
 Los Angeles , CA 90017
(800) 300-0001 5160 Birch Street
Suite 100
 Newport Beach, CA 92660
Lawrence Michael Knapp
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Stockton, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 24 years experience
(209) 946-4440 250 Dorris Pl
 Stockton, CA 95204
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Medical Malpractice and Nursing Home
Humphreys College
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Since 1993 I have been prosecuting negligent corporations and people who have hurt my clients. My main focus is to help injured people and their families. I have tried approximately 20 trials to verdict. I am on the Board of Consumer Attorneys of California and I am the defacto president of the San Joaquin County Trial Lawyers Association.
Ralph S. Curtis
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 44 years experience
(800) 529-3080 1300 K St
2nd Floor
 Modesto, CA 95354
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury
University of California - Davis and Pepperdine University School of Law
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
John Patrick Carty III
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 37 years experience
(209) 589-7220 615 13th Street
Suite B8
 Modesto, CA 95354
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury and Workers' Comp
University of California - Hastings College of the Law
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
John Carty graduated from UC Hastings College of the Law in San Francisco and passed the California Bar Examination, on his first attempt, in 1980. He has been a practicing California attorney since being sworn in on December 16, 1980. He has practiced law in Calaveras, Stanislaus, Sacramento, and San Joaquin Counties for his entire career.
(209) 477-0711 4537 Quail Lakes Drive
 Stockton, CA 95207
Patrick Curry
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Stockton, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 26 years experience
(209) 473-0394 5637 N Pershing Ave
 Stockton, CA 95207
Personal Injury, Divorce, Elder and Estate Planning
Humphreys College of Law
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Member of California and Federal Bar. Managing partner, current practice involves civil litigation, personal injury litigation for plaintiffs, defense, Probate, Consumer law, Family Law. As an Attorney, I am quite proficient in pleading and practice procedure, legal research in the library, web and computer, judicial procedure and rules of evidence. I have tried over a 200 court and jury trials. I have arbitrated and mediated over 500 cases. I have had experience with Superior, Appeals and Federal courts. I am a hearing officer for the City of Stockton and County of San Joaquin and a Pro...
Peter Fisher
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Attorney
(800) 529-3080 1300 K St
2nd Floor
 Modesto, CA 95354
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury
James E. Rogers College of Law, University of Arizona
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Robert Joseph Anaya
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 27 years experience
(209) 522-7500 1315 I Street
 Modesto, CA 95354
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, DUI, Family and Real Estate
University of San Francisco School of Law
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Christopher Der Manuelian
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Jackson, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 30 years experience
(209) 223-9000 847 No. Highway 88, Suite 3
 Jackson, CA 95642
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury
Santa Clara University School of Law
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Christopher Der Manuelian graduated from Santa Clara University in 1987 with both a law degree and an MBA. He worked as an insurance defense attorney in San Francisco and San Jose until 1997 when he opened his own practice representing people injured in accidents. He has handled all manner of personal injury cases spanning motor vehicle accidents, slip and falls, defective products and medical malpractice. His unique experience working for insurance companies afforded him intimate familiarity with the insurance claims process. He personally knows many of the claims adjusters in charge of handling claims for insurance companies, and...
(209) 774-9120 4545 Georgetown Place Suite B12
 Stockton, CA 95207
(209) 233-3199 1012 Carver Road, Suite C
 Modesto, CA 95350
Frederick J. Sette
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Stockton, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 23 years experience
(888) 516-6262 4568 Feather River Dr., Suite C
 Stockton, CA 95207
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury and Insurance Claims
University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
For the past 20 years all I have done is represent people who have been harmed in a personal injury accident, whether that accident was a car accident or some other sort of incident such as a dangerous condition of a product or someone's property. Harm includes medical bills, loss of income, and pain and suffering.
(888) 516-6262 1700 I St
Suite 120
 Sacramento, CA 95811
Steven August Fabbro
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 35 years experience
(209) 803-5117 1124 11th Street
 Modesto, CA 95354
Personal Injury and Elder
University of California Hastings College of the Law
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
With more than 30 years of legal experience, Steven A. Fabbro has built a reputation for himself as a highly skilled personal injury lawyer. Apart from the fact that he has single-handedly recovered more than $300 million in jury verdicts and settlements, he also offers clients the assurance that he is well-qualified to tackle the most complex of claims. In fact, Mr. Fabbro has a history of challenging large corporations in court, including insurance companies and product manufacturers, and winning. This, in turn, has helped him to earn a coveted AV® rating from the prestigious Martindale-Hubbell®. This is a...
Paul R. Scheele
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 13 years experience
(800) 529-3080 1300 K St
2nd Floor
 Modesto, CA 95354
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury
University of Miami School of Law
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Pamela Reynolds
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Lawyer
(800) 529-3080 1300 K St
2nd Floor
 Modesto, CA 95354
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury and Social Security Disability
Lincoln Law School
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Gerald Emmett Brunn
Claimed Profile
(209) 521-2133 928 12th Street, Suite 200
 Modesto, CA 95354
Personal Injury, Arbitration & Mediation, Business and Construction
U of San Francisco School of Law
Show Preview
View Website View Profile Email
San Francisco native Gerald E. Brunn holds Martindale-Hubbell‘s AV-Preeminent rating, confirming that he has reached “the height of professional excellence…and the highest levels of skill and integrity.” He represents clients in trials and litigation; personal injury and wrongful death cases; employment law; and business and corporate law matters. Mr. Brunn has served as a Special Master for the State Bar of California and is an adjunct professor at Chapman University and Modesto Junior College. He teaches Business Law, Employment and Labor Law, Constitutional Law, Legal History, and Political Science. Mr. Brunn received mediation training from the Straus Institute for...
Tai Christopher Bogan
Claimed Lawyer ProfileBlawgsearchSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 12 years experience
(209) 565-3425 615 13th St
#A
 Modesto, CA 95354
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Criminal, DUI and Products Liability
Humphreys College
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Mark Shane Nelson
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 31 years experience
(209) 529-6055 215 McHenry Ave
 Modesto, CA 95354
Personal Injury and Bankruptcy
Humphrey's Coll School of Law
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Injured? Going up against an insurance company? At the Law Offices of Mark S. Nelson, you pay nothing if there's no recovery. No attorney's fees. No expenses. Nothing. Their team of trial lawyers knows you face a tough battle against insurance companies and large corporations and take this burden off your shoulders. Learn more at your free consultation. Filing for bankruptcy can be a difficult decision. Attempting to tackle this decision alone is even more difficult. Contact us for assistance with resolving any bankruptcy issues including the following: Bankruptcy Non-Bankruptcy Alternatives Lawsuits Foreclosures Stop Garnishments Family law is complex. Our team is versed in a number of...
(209) 529-0995 215 McHenry Ave
 Modesto, CA 95354
Del Martyn Bohner
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 5 years experience
(209) 544-5727 948 11th Street
Suite 16
 Modesto, CA 95354
Personal Injury, Criminal and DUI
University of California - Hastings College of the Law
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Del Bohner provides aggressive representation in all criminal matters, from first time DUIs to murders. He has trial experience with very serious cases, including first degree burglary, robbery, and murder. He has also been successful in getting cases outright dismissed through the writing and arguing of pre-trial motions.
Roeuth Sam
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 10 years experience
(209) 222-3000 515 13th Street, Suite 205
 Modesto, CA 95354
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Insurance Claims and Medical Malpractice
California Western School of Law and California State University - Sacramento
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Mr. Roeuth Sam founded this firm after working for one of the biggest plaintiff’s personal injury firms in California. For the past eight years, Mr. Sam represented over a thousand injured clients. Mr. Sam worked in the pre-litigation department for several years handeling claims from the very beginning. Mr. Sam transferred into the litigation department and litigated hundreds of cases. Mr. Sam helped many injured victims navigate the complexities of litigation which included filing lawsuits, sending out and responding to written interrogatories, defending and taking depositions, retaining experts, appearing in court, arguing motions, attending mediations, arbitrations or settlement

Mr. Sam, a...
(916) 600-9016 9245 Laguna Springs Drive
Ste. 205
 Modesto, CA 95354
(209) 850-2828 4719 Quail Lakes Drive, Ste. G
 Stockton, CA 95207
(209) 600-4545 3144 G Street
 Merced, CA 95340
John Lawrence Gorman III
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 28 years experience
(209) 548-4000 1200 G St
Suite B
 Modesto, CA 95354
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Business, Estate Planning and Probate
Santa Clara Univ School of Law
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
I focus my legal practice on personal injury, estate planning & probate, business law, and civil litigation. If you are fighting for fair treatment, I can help. If you need advice regarding a trust or a will, I have extensive experience creating them and helping heirs and beneficiaries get what they deserve. If you want to protect your business and your livelihood, I am in your corner. If you’re injured and looking for a strong advocate, I am a plaintiff’s attorney prepared to help you fight back against insurance company tactics.
Mark Thiel
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Stockton, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 22 years experience
(209) 951-9600 3439 Brookside Rd #205
 Stockton, CA 95219
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Arbitration & Mediation and Employment
Humphrey's Coll School of Law and Humphreys College
Show Preview
View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
For over 20 years, Mr. Thiel has served clients in California's Central Valley in matters involving personal injury, wrongful termination & employment disputes, estate planning, probate, tax issues, and criminal law. Drawing on his knowledge and experience, he seeks to help you make informed decisions that work toward your best possible outcome. He is always upfront with you about your options and chances for success.

The depth of his experience includes recovering millions of dollars in settlements and court awards for injured victims, recovered real property wrongfully taken from unsuspecting parties, and redressed wrongs committed by employers against their employees....
Thomas Hogan
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Attorney
(209) 214-6600 1207 13th St.
 Modesto, CA 95354
Personal Injury, Bankruptcy, DUI and Divorce
University of California Hastings College of the Law
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile
The Thomas Hogan Law Office has vast experience when it comes to handling bankruptcy, divorce, family law, tax, DUI and Personal Injury cases. The Thomas Hogan Law Office is a family owned and operated business for over 25 years. You are not just a number at our office. We make it a point to meet with our clients personally.
Chad Bion Yates
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 11 years experience
(209) 408-8667 1301 L Street, Suite 1
 Modesto, CA 95354
Personal Injury, Business, Estate Planning and Probate
UC Hastings COL
View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Jude Redkey
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Sutter Creek, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 20 years experience
(916) 877-9700 105 Boston Alley
 Sutter Creek, CA 95685
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Insurance Claims and Products Liability
Univ of Denver COL
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Redkey Gordon Law Corp was formed in 2014. Jude Redkey has over 15 years of experience with personal injury matters. He focuses exclusively on personal injury matters which involved informal claim resolution and court litigation. Mr. Redkey has an active civil litigation practice, emphasizing personal injury law, including but not limited to; Auto Accidents; Wrongful Death; Uninsured and Under-Insured Motorist Claims; Back & Neck injuries; Big Rig Accidents; Burn Injuries or Scars; Motorcycle & Bicycle Accidents; Bus, Boat, Train, and Ski Accidents.
Nicholas David Yonano
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
El Dorado Hills, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 27 years experience
(916) 343-8488 4944 Windplay Drive
Suite 119
 El Dorado Hills, CA 95762
Personal Injury, Probate and Real Estate
Georgetown Univ Law Ctr
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Are you dealing with a complicated real estate or probate-related matter that needs the attention of a Sacramento attorney? If so, it may suit you to contact Yonano Law Offices, P.C. For nearly 20 years, Attorney Nick Yonano has been committed to helping his clients come up with solutions that are tailored to fit their specific needs and goals. While it can be stressful to be involved in a dispute, having an experienced litigator on your side can make a significant difference in your outcome. Mr. Yonano values forming long-lasting relationships with his clients, built on respect and trust. In...
George Steven Arata
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 41 years experience
(209) 522-2211 912 11th St #100
 Modesto, CA 95354
Personal Injury, Insurance Claims, Medical Malpractice and Products Liability
Western State Univ
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Eric Gutierrez
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 13 years experience
(800) 529-3080 1300 K St
2nd Floor
 Modesto, CA 95354
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury
University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Mark Curtis Shumar
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 28 years experience
(209) 571-2300 1601 I St
#350
 Modesto, CA 95354
Personal Injury, Business and Products Liability
Willamette Univ COL
Show Preview
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Attorney Marc S. Shumar received his Bachelor’s Degree from California State University, California, and his Juris Doctorate degree from Willamette University College of Law. The same year he graduated from law school, Mr. Shumarwas admitted to the California State Bar. He began his legal career as a lawyer representing insurance companies and defending cases against individuals who had been injured in accidents. After working with the firm for four years, Attorney Shumar realized that he did not always agree with the tactics used by insurance companies, and decided to establish his own firm. At The Law Offices of Mark C....
Tracy Y. Toledo
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Modesto, CA Personal Injury Attorney with 24 years experience
(209) 523-5000 920 16th Street, Suite D2
 Modesto, CA 95354
Personal Injury, Criminal, Divorce and Products Liability
Lincoln University
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer
Cory B. Chartrand
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Turlock, CA Personal Injury Lawyer with 24 years experience
(209) 667-2300 300 N. Palm Street
 Turlock, CA 95381
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Arbitration & Mediation, Insurance Claims and Products Liability
University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
View Website View Lawyer Profile Email Lawyer

Personal Injury Lawyers in Nearby Cities

Personal Injury Lawyers in Nearby Counties

FAQ Lawyers Get Listed

Related Practice Areas

Insurance Claims
Medical Malpractice
Products Liability

Injured in an accident?

When a person is injured, tort law will govern whether that person may be compensated for the injury, the amount of compensation that may be recovered, as well as which parties will be liable for the injury. Tort law, also known as injury law, comes from federal and state codes, as well as judicial opinions from prior cases. The amount of damages a plaintiff to a personal injury action may receive can be determined by statute, or by a judge or jury. Typical recoveries may include compensatory damages (e.g., lost wages, medical bills, etc.) and in particularly egregious situations, punitive damages. In some cases, a plaintiff may recover certain non-economic damages such as pain and suffering, loss of consortium, or loss of enjoyment of life.

Personal injury lawyers help injured people seek compensation from those who have harmed them. Some injury attorneys focus on a specific type of case, such as truck accidents, car accidents, slip-and-fall injuries, medical malpractice or products liability cases. If a person is injured as a result of criminal behavior, it may be appropriate to pursue a personal injury lawsuit in addition to the state's criminal investigation or prosecution.

Many personal injury attorneys offer a free consultation to evaluate your claim.

Negligence: Failure to use care which a reasonable and prudent person would use under similar circumstances.

Joint and several liability: A legal doctrine that makes each of the parties who are responsible for an injury, liable for all the damages awarded in a lawsuit if the other parties responsible cannot pay.

Researching Attorney Discipline

Find out whether an attorney has ever been disciplined.