Lebanon, Ohio Personal Injury Lawyers

Mr. Joseph T Ireland Esq.
PREMIUM

Personal Injury Attorney with 12 years experience

I give candid advice designed to empower my clients to make their best choice. Choose an attorney able to help you find your path forward. Give me a call 859-581-0123. Read More »
View Profile
Adam Michael Russell
PREMIUM

Personal Injury Lawyer with 12 years experience

My clients trust me to advocate for them with personal dignity, integrity, and independence. I gladly accept this responsibility and practice the same values when dealing with my colleagues. I am committed to achieving... Read More »
View Profile
Charles H. Rittgers Esq
PREMIUM

Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Lawyer with 41 years experience

Charles H. Rittgers, was named Top 100 Trial Lawyers by the American Trial Lawyers Association and is a member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum and the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum, groups limited to... Read More »
View Profile
Justin Lee Lawrence
PREMIUM

Working Hard for the Working Class

Justin L. Lawrence focuses his practice in the areas of personal injury, worker's compensation, maritime injuries, wrongful death, and bankruptcy. Justin is a 2002 Cum Laude graduate of the University of Kentucky with... Read More »
View Profile
Charles H. Rittgers Esq
Claimed Lawyer ProfileLII GoldSocial Media
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Lawyer with 41 years experience
(513) 932-2115 12 E Warren Street
Lebanon, OH 45036
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Criminal, Medical Malpractice and Products Liability
University of Cincinnati College of Law
Charles H. Rittgers, was named Top 100 Trial Lawyers by the American Trial Lawyers Association and is a member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum and the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum, groups limited to attorneys who have won million and multi-million dollar verdicts and settlements. Mr. Rittgers was selected again to the Ohio Super Lawyers list. He was also named in the Cincinnati Top 50 and the Ohio Top 100 lists.

Mr. Rittgers has handled numerous high publicity cases over his 30 years of practicing law and has been a guest speaker to local law enforcement groups. He has been...
Ryan J McGraw
Claimed Lawyer ProfileResponsive Law
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 7 years experience
(513) 932-2115 12 East Warren Street
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Business and Civil Rights
University of Cincinnati College of Law
Possessing extensive experience in both business transactions and counseling as well as a variety of civil litigation matters, Ryan J. McGraw is an attorney at Rittgers & Rittgers, Attorneys at Law. Located in Lebanon, Ohio, he provides representation to companies and individuals throughout the state where he was born and raised, and he is admitted to practice before all Ohio state courts.

Part of Ryan's business practice involves his representation of entrepreneurs who are starting a new venture. In this regard, he advises them as to the most appropriate form of legal entity that the business should operate under, and he...
Charles M. Rittgers
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 9 years experience
(513) 932-2115 12 East Warren Street
Lebanon, OH 45036
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Criminal and DUI
University of Cincinnati College of Law
Charles M. Rittgers is a trial lawyer with a record of success in criminal defense, DUI, and injury cases. Charlie's record includes not guilty jury verdicts in numerous cases in which no plea bargain was offered by the prosecutor, including murder, DUI, and domestic violence. In injury cases, Charlie is willing to take cases to trial that most lawyers would settle. For example, despite having a $1,000,000 offer from an insurance company to settle a motorcycle crash case, Charlie and his client refused the offer, took the case to a summary jury trial, and received a verdict of $9,000,000. ...
Jason A. Showen
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Lawyer with 19 years experience
(513) 282-6080 324 E. Warren St.
Lebanon, OH 45036
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Divorce, Family and Juvenile
University of Denver
Jason A. Showen is a native of Southwest, Ohio, who has lived and worked across the United States. He received his Bachelor’s Degree in Broadcasting from the University of Florida in 1987. He worked as a radio announcer for several years, also working in a variety of sales and management positions before attending the University of Denver Law School, focusing on trial and appellate advocacy. In addition, he worked for a Colorado District Court Judge as his law clerk before relocating back to Ohio.
Jason lives in Warren County with his wife, Jessie, and two children. He is an active member...
Gabriel P. Moorman
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Lawyer with 9 years experience
(513) 228-6024 212 N. Broadway Street
Lebanon, OH 45036
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Criminal, DUI and Divorce
University of Cincinnati College of Law
Compassionate, knowledgeable legal representation. Top 40 Under 40 Super Lawyers Rising Star Mr. Moorman is a Beavercreek native and a graduate of Carroll High School. He practices in the areas of Family Law (Domestic Relations) and Criminal Defense. He obtained his undergraduate degree from the University of Dayton, where he was awarded the President's Scholarship and was named to the Dean's Honors List. Gabe attended law school on a merit scholarship at the University of Cincinnati, College of Law, where he was named to the Dean's Honors List. While at UC, Gabe was president of the Intellectual Property Legal Society and a...
Barbara L. Strady
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 28 years experience
(513) 932-2115 12 East Warren Street
Lebanon, OH 45036
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury and Products Liability
University of Dayton School of Law
Barbara Strady devotes her law practice to helping injury victims. Barb is willing and eager to take difficult cases that other lawyers refuse because she wants to help people. She has a history of winning difficult cases for her clients. Barb puts herself in her clients’ shoes and takes a personal approach to each case she accepts. Most of Barb’s clients have her cell phone and consider Barb to be, not only their lawyer, but also a friend. Through this approach, Barb has made long lasting friendships with her former clients and frequently receives referrals...
David Edward Ernst
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 34 years experience
(513) 932-2214 11 S Broadway St
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Bankruptcy, Criminal and Family
University of Dayton School of Law
Ernst & Associates is an established and well-regarded firm representing a broad spectrum of clients, from major corporations to family-owned businesses throughout Ohio’s southwest counties. With more than 25 years of experience in family law matters, Ernst & Associates is known in the legal and client community as a firm whose team of talented attorneys offers dedicated, innovative and cost-effective legal services.
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Attorney
(513) 932-2121 304 E Warren St
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Business, Criminal and Divorce
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Lawyer
(513) 932-2047 42 E Silver St
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Bankruptcy, Business and Collections
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Lawyer
(513) 932-1836 24 N Broadway St
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Business, Elder and Estate Planning
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Attorney
(513) 932-2115 12 East Warren Street
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Business, Civil Rights and Social Security Disability
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Lawyer
(513) 934-5512 16 W Mulberry St
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Business, Criminal and Divorce
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Attorney
(513) 932-1515 144 E Mulberry St
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Arbitration & Mediation, Business and Estate Planning
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Attorney
(513) 932-2871 130 E Mulberry St
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Business, Medical Malpractice and Products Liability
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Attorney
(513) 932-2115 12 East Warren Street
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Lawyer
(513) 932-2115 12 E Warren St
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Business, Criminal and Divorce
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Attorney
(513) 932-2871 130 E Mulberry St
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Bankruptcy, Medical Malpractice and Products Liability
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Lawyer
(513) 932-4284 41 N Broadway St
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Bankruptcy, Business and Products Liability
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Lawyer
(937) 438-5588 20 Desales Ave
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Business, Employment and Products Liability
Lebanon, OH Personal Injury Lawyer
(513) 932-2047 42 E Silver St
Lebanon, OH 45036
Personal Injury, Bankruptcy, Business and Products Liability
Nathan M. Little
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Middletown, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 10 years experience
(513) 424-1660 1081 N. University Blvd Suite B
Suite B
Middletown, OH 45042
Personal Injury, Elder, Estate Planning and Landlord Tenant
University of Dayton School of Law
As a partner of Combs, Schaefer, Ball & Little Mr. Little has been dedicated to providing a wide range of legal assistance in Butler, Warren, Hamilton, Clermont, Greene, Montgomery, Preble and Guernsey counties with advanced legal representation. Although the home office is located in Middletown, Ohio he currently has cases pending in over eight Ohio counties. As a civil litigator and partner, Mr. Little has handled over 1,277 case files during the period of 2012 to 2017.

Throughout his career, Mr. Little has helped clients deal with both formation, purchase and sale of businesses, and the purchase, lease or...
Daniel Edward Haughey Esq
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Mason, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 19 years experience
(513) 234-0576 516 West Main Street
Mason, OH 45040
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Business, Criminal and Juvenile
University of Cincinnati College of Law
Dan Haughey is a Warren County lawyer who proudly represent clients throughout southwest Ohio in matters of criminal defense, personal injury, and business law. Partner at Haughey & Niehaus, Dan brings exceptional insights to every case he handles. As a former prosecutor, he is backed by the insider knowledge to craft a proactive defense for his clients, even in tough felony cases. As he has been elected to the office of part-time judge, his extensive legal experience has proven invaluable in his personal injury and business law practice. Contact his Warren County law firm 24/7 to find trusted legal answers.
William Randall Rock Esq
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Dayton, OH Personal Injury Lawyer with 35 years experience
(937) 224-7625 10817 Yankee Street
Dayton, OH 45458
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Insurance Claims, Medical Malpractice and Products Liability
University of Dayton School of Law
Legal matters can be intimidating, overwhelming and stressful. For over three decades I have had the privilege and satisfaction of helping people solve legal problems. Most who contact my office are experiencing difficult times and, therefore, legal representation must be competent, effective and conducted with intense enthusiasm and devotion to purpose. In a word, legal representation must be zealous. If you have a concern and seek professional legal advise, contact our office and schedule a FREE INITIAL and CONFIDENTIAL CONSULTATION to discuss your case. Our fees are reasonable, affordable and agreeable payment plans can...
Erik Niehaus
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Mason, OH Personal Injury Lawyer with 14 years experience
(513) 234-0576 516 West Main Street
Mason, OH 45040
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Criminal and Family
Northern Kentucky University
Erik Niehaus is a Warren County attorney who proudly serves clients across southwest Ohio in criminal defense, labor, and family law. Partner at Haughey & Niehaus, Erik is backed by extensive insights into the legal system. He served as a Miami University police officer before going on to serve for more than fifteen years at West Chester PD, where he eventually rose to the rank of police chief. During his service in law enforcement, Erik earned his J.D. He now provides insightful, skilled representation for clients facing criminal charges, business disputes, or divorce and custody issues. Call today!
Markus Moll
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Springboro, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 4 years experience
(937) 748-1004 62 Remick Blvd.
Springboro, OH 45066
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Criminal, Divorce and Family
University of Dayton School of Law
I have dedicated my legal career to protecting the interest and rights of those involved in domestic relations, juvenile, criminal, and civil matters. Throughout my career I have advised, and zealously advocated for clients on a broad range of personal matters relating to divorce, dissolution, child custody, shared parenting, asset allocation, spousal support, and post degree motions. I have also aggressively defended individuals in a wide variety of cases which span from misdemeanors to the most serious felonies.

I routinely practice in Butler, Clinton, Greene, Montgomery, and Warren County. However, my legal expertise has given me the privilege to advocate for...
Barbara Louise Horwitz Esq
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Springboro, OH Personal Injury Lawyer
(937) 750-8808 20 South Main Street
Springboro, OH 45066-2302
Personal Injury, Bankruptcy, Business and Insurance Claims
University of Cincinnati College of Law
Mason, OH Personal Injury Attorney
(513) 300-4882 5740 Gateway Boulevard
Suite 202
Mason, OH 45040
Personal Injury, Business, Divorce and Employment
Anthony Dean Castelli Esq
Claimed Lawyer ProfileQ&ABlawgsearchSocial Media
Cincinnati, OH Personal Injury Lawyer with 38 years experience
(513) 621-2345 8170 corporate park drive Ste 220
Cincinnati, OH 45242
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Arbitration & Mediation and Workers' Comp
Northern Kentucky University
As a Cincinnati Ohio personal injury lawyer and mediator, I can see where at a young age my parents instilled in me the need to help others. And my career path has always been about people that needed help. From working as a social worker helping abused and neglected children to working with disabled and emotionally challenged I've always been in the helping profession.

Since becoming a personal injury attorney in Cincinnati, Ohio over 30 years ago my passion for helping people continues. Except now, as a car accident injury trial lawyer I have the power...
John H. Phillips
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial MediaResponsive Law
Cincinnati, OH Personal Injury Lawyer with 30 years experience
(513) 985-2500 Phillips Law Firm, Inc.
9521 Montgomery Road
Cincinnati, OH 45242
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Business, Environmental and Insurance Claims
William Mitchell College of Law
A highly regarded litigator, John H. Phillips is the founder of the Phillips Law Firm, Inc. Located in Cincinnati, Ohio, he provides representation to individual and business clients throughout the greater metropolitan area. Admitted to practice before all Ohio and Minnesota state courts, Mr. Phillips is also admitted to practice before several federal trial and appellate courts.

Mr. Phillips devotes a significant portion of his practice to business litigation. The types of cases that he has handled in this regard have included trade secret misappropriation, contract breaches, partner and shareholder actions, and purchase and sale disputes. Mr. Phillips also has extensive...
Marisa Dyson
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
West Chester, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 5 years experience
(513) 351-5997 4837 Rialto Road
Suite A
West Chester, OH 45069
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury and Workers' Comp
Salmon P. Chase College of Law, Northern Kentucky University
Marisa Dyson focuses her practice in the areas of Workers Compensation and Personal Injury. Marisa gained extensive experience in Workers' Compensation law with a defense firm, but her heart led her to sympathize with the injured workers and their families that she saw on the other side of the courtroom. Because of this, she joined Lawrence & Associates to help represent injured workers and their families in Workers' Compensation and Personal Injury cases throughout Cincinnati and Southwest Ohio.

Marisa graduated at the top of her class, magna cum laude from Salmon P. Chase College of law in 2014. During her...
Joseph M Braun
Claimed Lawyer ProfileQ&ASocial Media
Hamilton, OH Personal Injury Lawyer with 3 years experience
(513) 887-4560 616 Dayton Street
Hamilton, OH 45011
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Estate Planning, Probate and Real Estate
Capital University Law School
Inside the courtroom or over a cup of coffee, Joseph Braun is your trusted source of legal advice, professional representation and strategic planning. A strong regulatory background gives Joseph an advantage in finding the nooks and crannies in the law that enables Joseph to plan for contingencies, work through your problem, or remedy a potential crisis. Joseph practices estate planning, probate law, real estate law, adoption law, and more. Outside of work Joseph enjoys hiking and camping with his wife, playing with his dachshund son Ludwig, and attending church at the Oaks Community Church in Middletown.
John Mark Williams Esq
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Cincinnati, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 25 years experience
(877) 272-0633 8280 Montgomery Road, Suite 110
Cincinnati, OH 45236
Personal Injury, Bankruptcy and Insurance Defense
Salmon P. Chase College of Law, Northern Kentucky University
We understand legal fires and how to put them out. You need a law firm with broad experience to make your life easier not harder. The Law Office of John M. Williams, LLC, is here to make your life easier and to put out that fire. We focus on the legal fires of consumer bankruptcy, wrongful death of a loved one, car accidents that caused personal injury, insurance defense litigation, and appeals of Veterans benefits and service connected benefits. We can help you with your civil cases small claims court, municipal court, common pleas court, and federal...
Justin Lee Lawrence
Claimed Lawyer ProfileQ&ALII GoldSocial Media
West Chester , OH Personal Injury Attorney with 14 years experience
(513) 351-5997 4837 Rialto Road Suite A
West Chester , OH 45069
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Bankruptcy, Products Liability and Workers' Comp
Salmon P. Chase College of Law, Northern Kentucky University
Justin L. Lawrence focuses his practice in the areas of personal injury, worker's compensation, maritime injuries, wrongful death, and bankruptcy. Justin is a 2002 Cum Laude graduate of the University of Kentucky with Bachelor degrees in Accounting and Business Administration. While at the University of Kentucky, he was awarded the prestigious Woodson B. Gudgell scholarship. He earned his Juris Doctor degree from the Salmon P. Chase College of Law in 2005. In law school, he served as Vice President of the SBA and Justice of Phi Alpha Delta's Hoffman Chapter. Justin was also honored with the Alex P. Hotchkiss Award...
Joshua Hodges
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Hamilton, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 4 years experience
(513) 894-3333 220 South Monument Avenue Suite 100
Hamilton, OH 45011
Personal Injury and Criminal
Northern Kentucky University
Josh Hodges has worked as a cashier, a busboy, a bartender, a machine operator, a drivers license examiner, an attorney at one of the largest law firms in the Midwestern United States, and is now the co-founder of Kruger and Hodges, LLC. His path to becoming a lawyer was long and it taught him that perseverance pays off and to not be afraid to take risks. Along the way, he was lucky enough to work beside people who work every day just to make ends meet, very successful professionals who assist some of the largest corporations in the...
Kara Harp
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Cincinnati, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 5 years experience
(800) 698-4054 8044 Montgomery Rd #700
Cincinnati, OH 45236
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Civil Rights and Medical Malpractice
Salmon P. Chase College of Law, Northern Kentucky University
Kara is a 2009 graduate of the University of Kentucky where she earned a Bachelor of Arts, summa cum laude, in Communication and a minor in Psychology. Kara graduated manga cum laude from Salmon P. Chase College of Law at Northern Kentucky University in 2014. She was one of only two students in her graduating class to earn a Certificate for Excellence in Advocacy, which represents leadership skills and coursework emphasizing written and oral advocacy, pre-trial and trial skills and alternative dispute resolution.

Kara was very active in law school, serving as a member of the Moot Court Board, the Executive...
Mr. Monte Kenneth Snyder Esq
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Middletown, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 34 years experience
(513) 423-8912 6501 Germantown Road
Lot 41
Middletown, OH 45042
Personal Injury, Divorce, Family and Juvenile
University of Dayton
I am available to Dayton area clients at 4130 Linden Avenue, Claypool Building, Suite 304, Dayton, Ohio, courtesy of my good friend, R. Jason Howard, (by appointment only) I'm always available by phone & email. As a solo practitioner, you deal only with me, no paralegals or assistants. This allows me to provide a personal touch to your legal representation other law firms only promise but are unable to deliver. The attorney/client relationship is a team effort. Your active participation in your case is essential for effective representation. Suggestions, questions & ideas are welcome & encouraged at Monte...
Justin M. McMullen
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Dayton, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 8 years experience
(937) 276-9700 3033 Kettering Boulevard, Suite 213
Dayton, OH 45439
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury
University of Dayton School of Law
Mark Edward Godbey Esq
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
West Chester, OH Personal Injury Lawyer with 30 years experience
(513) 777-1701 8050 Beckett Center Dr. Suite 322
West Chester, OH 45069
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Bankruptcy, Business and Family
University of Akron
I am a native of Cincinnati and have been actively practicing law for over 22 years. We are a full-service law firm of five attorneys, representing clients and small businesses in a variety of matters, including auto accidents and other kinds of personal injury law, bankruptcy and debt consolidation, divorce and other aspects of family law, probate, estate planning, criminal and traffic cases, etc. We have offices in downtown Cincinnati, West Chester, Dayton and Florence, Kentucky. We offer a free initial consultation, affordable rates and payment terms. Our attorneys strive for the best legal results while also giving...
Stephen P O'Keefe Esq
Claimed Lawyer ProfileSocial Media
Dayton, OH Personal Injury Attorney with 24 years experience
(937) 643-0600 7385 Far Hills Ave.
Dayton, OH 45459
Free ConsultationPersonal Injury, Medical Malpractice and Nursing Home
Cleveland-Marshall College of Law
Our focus on obtaining just compensation for our clients has allowed us to achieve many multimillion dollar verdicts and settlements, including one of the largest medical malpractice verdicts in Montgomery County history. We know and understand how difficult it is when an individual or family member suffers a horrible tragedy or death through the fault of medical professionals. When an individual or family member is injured as a result of medical care, the medical system does not provide answers to their questions. We will get your questions answered. We represent individuals and families who have been...
Matthew T. Dixon
Claimed Lawyer Profile
Middletown, OH Personal Injury Lawyer with 19 years experience
(513) 422-4227 16 North Main Street
Middletown, OH 45042
Personal Injury, Bankruptcy, Criminal and Divorce
Mississippi College School of Law
A Middletown, Ohio, native, Matthew T. Dixon is a graduate of Edgewood High School in nearby Trenton. He earned his undergraduate degree from his grandfather's alma mater, Mississippi State University, in 1996 and his doctor of jurisprudence, magna cum laude, from the Mississippi College School of Law in 2000. Prior to returning to his hometown, he was employed as the senior associate attorney at the law firm of Henley, Lotterhos & Henley, PLLC, in Jackson, Mississippi, practicing primarily in the fields of debtor/creditor law and insurance subrogation. Previously, he had assisted in criminal defense as a legal...
Lawyer Rating
Years of Experience
Language
Fees
Profile Strength
Personal Injury Lawyers in Nearby CitiesPersonal Injury Lawyers in Nearby Counties

Lebanon Personal Injury Legal Aid & Pro Bono Services

Legal Aid of Greater Cincinnati
Hamilton, OH

Show More

Injured in an accident?

When a person is injured, tort law will govern whether that person may be compensated for the injury, the amount of compensation that may be recovered, as well as which parties will be liable for the injury. Tort law, also known as injury law, comes from federal and state codes, as well as judicial opinions from prior cases. The amount of damages a plaintiff to a personal injury action may receive can be determined by statute, or by a judge or jury. Typical recoveries may include compensatory damages (e.g., lost wages, medical bills, etc.) and in particularly egregious situations, punitive damages. In some cases, a plaintiff may recover certain non-economic damages such as pain and suffering, loss of consortium, or loss of enjoyment of life.

Personal injury lawyers help injured people seek compensation from those who have harmed them. Some injury attorneys focus on a specific type of case, such as truck accidents, car accidents, slip-and-fall injuries, medical malpractice or products liability cases. If a person is injured as a result of criminal behavior, it may be appropriate to pursue a personal injury lawsuit in addition to the state's criminal investigation or prosecution.

Many personal injury attorneys offer a free consultation to evaluate your claim.


Negligence: Failure to use care which a reasonable and prudent person would use under similar circumstances.

Joint and several liability: A legal doctrine that makes each of the parties who are responsible for an injury, liable for all the damages awarded in a lawsuit if the other parties responsible cannot pay.