California Civil Jury Instructions (CACI)
5009. Predeliberation Instructions
When you go to the jury room, the first thing you should do is choose a presiding juror. The presiding juror should see to it that your discussions are orderly and that everyone has a fair chance to be heard.
It is your duty to talk with one another in the jury room and to consider the views of all the jurors. Each of you must decide the case for yourself, but only after you have considered the evidence with the other members of the jury. Feel free to change your mind if you are convinced that your position should be different. You should all try to agree. But do not give up your honest beliefs just because the others think differently.
Please do not state your opinions too strongly at the beginning of your deliberations. Also, do not immediately announce how you plan to vote. Keep an open mind so that you and your fellow jurors can easily share ideas about the case.
You should use your common sense, but do not use or consider any special training or unique personal experience that any of you have in matters involved in this case. Such training or experience is not a part of the evidence received in this case.
Sometimes jurors disagree or have questions about the evidence or about what the witnesses said in their testimony. If that happens, you may ask to have testimony read back to you or ask to see any exhibits admitted into evidence that have not already been provided to you. Also, jurors may need further explanation about the laws that apply to the case. If this happens during your discussions, write down your questions and give them to the clerk or bailiff. I will do my best to answer them. When you write me a note, do not tell me how you voted on an issue until I ask for this information in open court.
[At least nine jurors must agree on each verdict and on each question that you are asked to answer. However, the same jurors do not have to agree on each verdict or each question. Any nine jurors is sufficient. As soon as you have agreed on a verdict and answered all the questions as instructed, the presiding juror must date and sign the form(s) and notify the clerk or the bailiff.]
Your decision must be based on your personal evaluation of the evidence presented in the case. Each of you may be asked in open court how you voted on each question.
While I know you would not do this, I am required to advise you that you must not base your decision on chance, such as a flip of a coin. If you decide to award damages, you may not agree in advance to simply add up the amounts each juror thinks is right and then make the average your verdict.
You may take breaks, but do not discuss this case with anyone, including each other, until all of you are back in the jury room.
Directions for Use
The Advisory Committee recommends that this instruction be read to the jury after closing arguments and after reading instructions on the substantive law.
The sixth paragraph is bracketed because this point appears in the special verdict form instructions. Read this paragraph if the special verdict instruction (CACI No. 5012, Introduction to Special Verdict Form) is not also being read.
Judges may want to provide each juror with a copy of the verdict forms so that the jurors can use it to keep track of how they vote. Jurors can be instructed that this copy is for their personal use only and that the presiding juror will be given the official verdict form to record the jury's decision. Judges may also want to advise jurors that they may be polled in open court regarding their individual verdicts.
Delete the reference to reading back testimony in cases where the proceedings are not being recorded.
Sources and Authority
Code of Civil Procedure section 613 provides, in part: "When the case is finally submitted to the jury, they may decide in court or retire for deliberation; if they retire, they must be kept together, in some convenient place, under charge of an officer, until at least three-fourths of them agree upon a verdict or are discharged by the court."
Code of Civil Procedure section 614 provides: "After the jury have retired for deliberation, if there be a disagreement between them as to ny part of the testimony, or if they desire to be informed of any point of law arising in the cause, they may require the officer to conduct them into court. Upon their being brought into court, the information required must be given in the presence of, or after notice to, the parties or counsel."
Code of Civil Procedure section 618 and article I, section 16, of the California Constitution provide that three-fourths of the jurors must agree to a verdict in a civil case.
The prohibition on chance or quotient verdict is stated in Code of Civil Procedure section 657, which provides that a verdict may be vacated and a new trial ordered "whenever any one or more of the jurors have been induced to assent to any general or special verdict, or to a finding on any question submitted to them by the court, by a resort to the determination of chance." (See also Chronakis v. Windsor (1993) 14 Cal.App.4th 1058, 1064-1065 [18 Cal.Rptr.2d 106].)
Jurors should be encouraged to deliberate on the case. (Vomaska v. City of San Diego (1997) 55 Cal.App.4th 905, 911 [64 Cal.Rptr.2d 492].)
The jurors may properly be advised of the duty to hear and consider each other's arguments with open minds, rather than preventing agreement by stubbornly sticking to their first impressions. (Cook v. Los Angeles Ry. Corp. (1939) 13 Cal.2d 591, 594 [91 P.2d 118].)
7 Witkin, California Procedure (4th ed. 1997) Trial, §§ 330, 336
4 California Trial Guide, Unit 91, Jury Deliberations and Rendition of Verdict, § 91.01 (Matthew Bender)
28 California Forms of Pleading and Practice, Ch. 326, Jury Instructions, § 326.32, Ch. 326A, Jury Verdicts, § 326A.14 (Matthew Bender)
(Revised October 2004)